Butcher Shop - Our online store for our fine meats and sauces
Shopping Cart more
0 items
Grass Fed BeefGrass Fed BuffaloOur PantryUSDA Prime BeefSteak BurgersPorkAll-Natural LambAll-Natural VealPoultryMeaty GiftsGift CertificatesMerchandise
USDA Prime Beef
    "If my steaks weren't the BEST, I wouldn't dare put my family name on them" Ottomanelli, yes we deliver!"

    Ottomanelli Brothers Grilling Techniques

Chateaubriand, the Queen of Roasts Chateaubriand, the Queen of Roasts

The USDA Prime Chateaubriand is the perfect way to savor steak in its most glorious steak, carved from the very heart of the tenderloin, no other cut is quite as elegant, easy to prepare, delicious, tender and oven ready.

View details

3 1/2 lbs. (56oz) : ($198.75) QTY:  


Complete Trimmed Filet Mignon Complete Trimmed Filet Mignon

Nothing matches the incomparable taste and delicacy of Ottomanelli Bros. USDA Prime Filet Mignon. They are undeniably the perfect combination of rich grain-fed mildness and exquisite tenderness.

View details

4 (6oz) Filet Mignons : 1" thick ($99.95) QTY:  

6 (6oz) Filet Mignons : 1" thick ($129.00) QTY:  

8 (6oz) Filet Mignons : 1" thick ($189.99) QTY:  


London Broil London Broil

Most London Broils are cut from flank steak, but our USDA Prime London Broil is cut from lean sirloin...so it's the heartiest, most delicious London Broil you'll ever taste!

View details

2 (32oz) : ($99.95) QTY:  


Ottomanelli Brothers Steak Sampler Ottomanelli Brothers Steak Sampler

2 (8oz) USDA Prime Filet Mignons

2 (14-16oz) USDA Prime Boneless Rib Steaks

2 (16oz) USDA Prime N.Y. Sirloin Steaks

View details

$169.85

QTY:

Ottomanelli Brothers' Weekend Special Ottomanelli Brothers' Weekend Special

8 (5oz) Steak Burgers

6 (14-16oz) USDA Prime N.Y. Sirloin Steaks

1 Bottle of Ottomanelli Brothers Steak Sauce

View details

$269.95

QTY:

USDA Prime Dry-Aged Boneless N.Y. Sirloin USDA Prime Dry-Aged Boneless N.Y. Sirloin

Juicy and flavorful, these USDA Prime Boneless Strip Steaks are carved from the heart of the short loin.

View details

6(14-16oz) Boneless N.Y. Sirloin : 1" thick ($249.00) QTY:  

8(14-16oz) Boneless N.Y. Sirloin : 1" thick ($289.00) QTY:  


USDA Prime Rib Eye Steak USDA Prime Rib Eye Steak

Our USDA Prime Rib Eye Steaks have a fanatical following......and after just one bite, you'll know why! Carved from the center of a Prime Rib Roast, these generously marbled steaks combine the sublime texture of aged beefsteak with the mellow flavor of Prime Rib.

View details

4 (14-16oz) Prime Rib Eye Steaks : 1" thick ($119.85) QTY:  

8 (14-16oz) Prime Rib Eye Steaks : 1" thick ($198.95) QTY:  


USDA Prime Rib Roast USDA Prime Rib Roast

The Prime Rib Roast has long been rivaled by other fine roasts, but its robust taste and melt-in-your-mouth texture have kept it on the top of America's list of favorites. This incredibly tender, easy to prepare roast is cut from the heart of the rib - boneless, juicy and mouth-watering to the very last morsel. For yourself or as an impressive gift, Ottomanelli Brothers' Prime Rib Roasts are truly unsurpassed

View details

12 to 14 lbs. - 4 Ribs : ($298.95) QTY:  

17 to 20 lbs. - 7 Ribs : ($389.95) QTY:  


USDA Prime T-Bone Steaks USDA Prime T-Bone Steaks

A big juicy USDA Prime T-bone is the traditional favorite of serious steak fans! On one side of the "T" is a portion of tender filet mignon - on the other side is a whole strip sirloin steak.

View details

2 (32oz) T-Bones : 1" thick ($129.95) QTY:  

4 (32oz) T-Bones : 1" thick ($198.95) QTY:  

Chateaubriand, the Queen of Roasts. Easy to prepare, delicious, tender and oven ready.
An Italian American Restuarant with a Family Tradition.
~Since 1900~

Two NY Locations

• New Carnegie Hill News
• New York Magazine
• New York Times
• Town & Country
• ZAGAT Survey
OTTOMANELLI BROTHERS 1549 York Avenue (Corner of 82nd Street) T: 212.772.7900 F: 212.772.8436